Smartphones, livestreams, and social media are changing how the world witnesses history. These technologies empower individuals to capture and share real-time events, blurring the lines between observer and participant. But as everyday people become frontline reporters, what happens to the institutions that once controlled the news?
Traditional media outlets find themselves challenged by this surge of citizen journalism, forcing them to adapt quickly or risk becoming obsolete. Moreover, the immediacy of social media means that news spreads faster than ever, often without the vetting processes that ensure accuracy. This shift not only influences public perception but also raises questions about accountability, bias, and the role of professional journalists in a rapidly evolving landscape of information dissemination.
When Everyone Has a Platform
The modern media landscape is no longer dominated solely by journalists in newsrooms or anchors on national television. With a smartphone and an internet connection, anyone can capture breaking news, share lived experiences, and offer commentary that travels far beyond their local community.
This democratization of information is what we now recognize as citizen journalism, a grassroots approach to storytelling that relies on everyday individuals to document events, often in real-time. Whether it’s a protest, natural disaster, or local government scandal, these on-the-ground perspectives offer immediacy, authenticity, and diversity that traditional newsrooms can struggle to match.
But this rise comes with tension. As citizen journalists reshape how the public consumes information, legacy media must grapple with declining trust, shifting authority, and the need to adapt or risk irrelevance.
A Brief History of Citizen Journalism
While the term gained traction in the digital age, the concept isn’t new. Ordinary citizens have long participated in news production. What’s changed is scale and speed. The 2000s ushered in a wave of online platforms that gave people the tools to report and broadcast independently.
Then came the social media era. With Facebook, Twitter (now X), Instagram, and TikTok, reporting moved from blogs to livestreams, transforming the way information is disseminated and consumed. These platforms have democratized reporting, allowing anyone with a smartphone to share their perspective with the world in real-time. In the past decade, citizen journalism has not only emerged as a powerful tool for storytelling but has also played a crucial role in exposing human rights violations and offering a voice to the voiceless.
It has helped hold police accountable by recording incidents that would otherwise go unnoticed, ensuring that injustices are brought to light. Furthermore, citizen journalists have shaped the global narrative of social movements like Black Lives Matter, creating a vital space for dialogue and fostering connections across communities. This shift has significantly influenced public opinion and policy, underscoring the importance of grassroots efforts in driving social change.
Why Citizen Journalism Resonates Today
1. Speed and Access
Mainstream media outlets have editorial processes, gatekeeping structures, and logistical limitations. Citizen journalists, by contrast, are often first responders with the footage to prove it. When a major event unfolds, the first images usually come not from a professional crew but a bystander’s phone.
2. Authenticity Over Polish
Audiences, particularly Gen Z and Millennials, are increasingly skeptical of polished media narratives. They seek raw, unfiltered content that feels closer to the truth. Citizen journalism taps into that hunger for authenticity, especially in conflict zones or marginalized communities where traditional media may have limited access or inherent biases.
3. Representation and Inclusion
Traditional media has historically privileged certain voices — often white, male, and elite. Citizen journalism allows for a broader spectrum of perspectives, especially from underrepresented or oppressed groups. For many, it’s not just about reporting news, it’s about reclaiming their narrative.
Case Studies That Have Altered Citizen Journalism
George Floyd
The 2020 murder of George Floyd by a Minneapolis police officer was captured on a bystander’s smartphone, not by a local news station. The footage, shared online, sparked a global reckoning with racism and police brutality. It was a watershed moment for citizen journalism, demonstrating its ability to force accountability and catalyze movements in ways institutional media struggled to do.
Ukraine’s War Diaries on TikTok
As Russia invaded Ukraine in 2022, young Ukrainians took to TikTok and Instagram to document their lives under siege. These firsthand accounts didn’t just supplement mainstream war coverage — they defined it. Traditional outlets began citing viral posts and videos, further legitimizing citizen voices in serious geopolitical reporting.
Gaza, Sudan, and Decolonizing Media Narratives
In conflict zones often underserved by Western media, citizen journalists and local activists have taken the lead in documenting violence, war crimes, and humanitarian crises. Their content is frequently shared through social media aggregators and independent networks like AJ+, NowThis, and independent Substacks, raising questions about who controls the truth in the age of virality.
The Challenges of Citizen Journalism
Despite its many strengths, citizen journalism is not without serious concerns:
1. Verification and Misinformation
Without editorial oversight, false or misleading content can spread rapidly. Deepfakes, miscaptioned videos, and propaganda disguised as “on-the-ground reporting” can create chaos. The viral nature of social media means that by the time traditional outlets fact-check a claim, the damage may already be done.
2. Lack of Accountability
Professional journalists are held to ethical standards and legal regulations. Citizen journalists often aren’t, which raises the risk of defamation, privacy violations, or biased reporting. While some operate with integrity, others may prioritize virality or personal agendas over truth.
3. Safety and Exploitation
Citizen journalists, especially those in authoritarian regimes or conflict zones, face serious threats. Without institutional support or legal protections, they risk arrest, violence, or worse. In some cases, media outlets or online users exploit their content without credit or compensation, raising ethical concerns around labor and intellectual property.
Traditional Media
The rise of citizen journalism has forced legacy media to rethink their role in society. Some see it as a threat; others, an opportunity.
The Decline of Institutional Trust
Trust in mainstream media has plummeted. A 2023 Gallup poll showed that only 32% of Americans trust mass media “a great deal” or “a fair amount.” This erosion is partially fueled by perceptions of bias, corporate influence, and disconnect from everyday realities — gaps that citizen journalism often fills.
The Rise of Hybrid Models
To stay relevant, many outlets are adopting hybrid approaches, incorporating user-generated content, partnering with local reporters, and leveraging social media to crowdsource footage and leads. CNN’s iReport and BBC’s User-Generated Content Hub were early efforts; more recently, The New York Times and Reuters have featured citizen videos in investigative reporting.
The Journalist as a Curator
The future of journalism may lie in curation, not creation. Professional reporters increasingly act as verifiers, fact-checkers, and storytellers who contextualize citizen footage within broader narratives. This shift doesn’t eliminate the need for traditional journalism — it redefines it.
Gen Z and the New Information Ecosystem
For Gen Z, who grew up online, citizen journalism feels more intuitive than nightly news. According to a 2024 Pew Research Center study, over 60% of Americans aged 18-29 say they get most of their news from TikTok, YouTube, or Instagram, platforms where citizen content thrives.
This shift also influences how news is consumed: visually, quickly, and emotionally. Short-form video, emotional storytelling, and participatory discourse (e.g., stitching, duetting, commenting) are reshaping how truth is constructed and debated in public.
But with this decentralization comes responsibility. Gen Z is not just a passive audience; they are curators, amplifiers, and critics. Their engagement determines what stories trend, what narratives are questioned, and what truths are upheld.
Regulation, Ethics, and the Future
As lines blur between journalist and citizen, the media ecosystem faces unresolved questions:
- Should citizen journalists be legally protected like traditional reporters?
- How can platforms combat misinformation without stifling grassroots reporting?
- What ethical standards should apply when documenting trauma or violence?
Some solutions are emerging: initiatives like First Draft and the Trust Project promote digital literacy and responsible sourcing. Universities and NGOs are offering training for citizen journalists on ethics and verification. Meanwhile, platforms like YouTube and TikTok have begun labeling state-affiliated or manipulated content to improve transparency.
Still, the future remains uncertain and highly decentralized.
Conclusion: The Transformation
Citizen journalism is not replacing traditional media; it’s transforming it.
In a world where institutions are questioned and lived experience carries weight, the future of journalism belongs to those who can blend credibility with accessibility, speed with accuracy, and voice with ethics.
The challenge is not whether citizen journalism is valid; it is. The challenge is how we integrate this growing form of expression into a media ecosystem that informs, protects, and empowers the public.
For traditional media, the choice is clear: adapt and collaborate, or risk fading into irrelevance.
For the rest of us, it’s a call to be more thoughtful consumers, more responsible sharers, and when the moment demands, courageous storytellers.
References
Pew Research Center
“News Consumption Across Social Media in 2024.”
https://www.pewresearch.org
Gallup
“Americans’ Trust in Media Remains Near Record Low.” (2023)
https://news.gallup.com/poll/403166/americans-trust-mass-media-remains-near-record-low.aspx
The New York Times
“How TikTok Became a Tool for Ukrainian Citizens During Wartime.”
https://www.nytimes.com
BBC News
“The Bystander Who Filmed George Floyd’s Death.”
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-52869538
Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism
“Digital News Report 2023.”
https://reutersinstitute.politics.ox.ac.uk/digital-news-report/2023
Columbia Journalism Review
“What Happens When the News Is No Longer a Shared Experience?”
https://www.cjr.org
Harvard Kennedy School – Shorenstein Center
“Citizen Journalism and the Public Sphere: Redefining the Journalist.”
https://shorensteincenter.org
The Guardian
“From Ferguson to Minneapolis: How Smartphone Footage Changed the Narrative on Police Brutality.”
https://www.theguardian.com
The Trust Project
“Restoring Trust in News Through Transparency and Standards.”
https://thetrustproject.org
Columbia Journalism School
“Journalism Ethics for the Digital Age.”
https://journalism.columbia.edu
Olivia Santoro is a writer and communications creative focused on media, digital culture, and social impact, particularly where communication intersects with society. She’s passionate about exploring how technology, storytelling, and social platforms shape public perception and drive meaningful change. Olivia also writes on sustainability in fashion, emerging trends in entertainment, and stories that reflect Gen Z voices in today’s fast-changing world.
Connect with her here: https://www.linkedin.com/in/olivia-santoro-1b1b02255/
About The Author
